The XII International Forum on the Case-Law of the European Court of Human Rights took place online on October 29, 2023, in Kyiv, gathering judges, state officials, and experts to evaluate Ukraine’s progress in human rights implementation. Key achievements highlighted the successful supervision of judgements, while persistent challenges, such as lengthy judicial processes and ineffective investigations, were also discussed.
On October 29, 2023, a vibrant online gathering took place—the XII International Forum on the Case-Law of the European Court of Human Rights, focused on implementing the European Convention on Human Rights in Ukraine. This forum, held in the bustling heart of Kyiv, united judges, state representatives, academic voices, civil society advocates, and international experts in a shared ambition to improve the human rights landscape of Ukraine. Amidst the discussions, the Department for the Execution of Judgments showcased significant strides made in this crucial domain. Recent decisions by the Committee of Ministers highlighted advancements following the review of the Balitskiy/Yaremenko groups, where essential safeguards concerning legal representation and evidence admissibility are being strengthened. Similarly, the supervision of the Chanyev case was wrapped up, marking an end to monitoring since robust legislation on pre-trial detention has been adopted. However, challenges linger like shadows in the background. Unresolved issues such as the non-enforcement and delays in judicial decisions, excessive trial lengths, and ineffective investigations were spotlighted in the discussion. Specifically, the Zhovner/Ivanov and Burmych groups, along with the Merit and Afanasyev/Kaverzin groups, exemplified the systemic obstacles that continue to obstruct justice. A focused panel on judicial integrity further delved into concerns over the independence and impartiality that are pivotal for the judiciary’s credibility. The event was artfully orchestrated by the Supreme Court, in collaboration with esteemed institutions like the Ivan Franko National University of Lviv and the National School of Judges of Ukraine, alongside support from the OSCE and Council of Europe initiatives.
This forum served as a critical platform for exploring the intersection of Ukraine’s legal framework and human rights obligations under European law. As Ukraine continues navigating complex judicial landscapes—marked by both achievements and persistent challenges—the discussions at the forum offered insights into the effective implementation of human rights judgments. The gathering sought to foster a dialogue among various stakeholders to reinforce a commitment to uphold the rule of law and protect civil rights across the nation.
The XII International Forum illustrated a pivotal moment in Ukraine’s journey towards enhancing human rights protections through effective implementation of European Court judgments. While significant progress has been made, the road ahead is fraught with challenges requiring renewed commitment and cooperation among all stakeholders. The discussions emphasized the importance of integrity within the judiciary as a cornerstone for rebuilding public trust in the legal system.
Original Source: www.coe.int
