On March 16, 2025, Newcastle United achieved a momentous victory by winning the Carabao Cup Final, their first domestic trophy in over 55 years. While this milestone filled fans with joy, it simultaneously highlighted serious concerns regarding the club’s Saudi ownership, particularly the human rights abuses prevalent in the kingdom, overshadowing their celebratory triumph.
The strife experienced in Saudi Arabia raises questions about the implications of the Saudi Public Investment Fund’s ownership. Some fans argue that the cup win legitimises their involvement, viewing it as a sign of improved governance at the club. However, many remain worryingly aware of the ongoing human rights violations that should not be overlooked despite the celebratory atmosphere.
One significant issue revolves around the harsh prison sentences for dissenters like Manahel al-Otaibi, sentenced for her online expression and perceived inappropriate attire. A November 2024 Human Rights Watch report connects such abuses to the regime associated with the PIF, raising scepticism about any real change since the victory, as al-Otaibi’s situation continues unchanged amidst the jubilation in Wembley.
Another layer of injustice lies in the exploitation of migrant workers through the Kafala system, with alarming statistics emerging over the past five years, indicating the tragic deaths of at least 274 Kenyan women due to poor working conditions. Many migrant workers from East Africa face grim realities of abuse and unpaid wages. On the same day as the cup final, The New York Times echoed these atrocities, highlighting the painful contrast between celebration in England and silent suffering in Saudi Arabia.
Progress on women’s rights in Saudi Arabia remains stagnant; the recent Personal Status Law created on March 8, 2022, has been criticised by Amnesty International as reinforcing male guardianship rather than abolishing it. This persistent control limits women’s autonomy over critical life choices, like marriage and custody, deepening the challenges they face each day.
As Newcastle United’s supporters bask in their victory, they must confront the moral implications that accompany such achievements against a backdrop of oppression. The joy of football and an ethical awareness of human rights issues must strive to coexist.
Newcastle’s legacy distinguishing solidarity and justice beckons its fans to consider the ethical ramifications of its ownership. Known historically for humanitarian efforts, the club must continue to spotlight human rights issues as it progresses.
Additionally, the club grapples with player contract negotiations, particularly regarding defender Fabian Schar, whose contract is nearing its end. Schar, 34, has made a notable contribution to the team since joining in 2018, and his importance to the squad is endorsed by head coach Eddie Howe, who celebrated his tactical flexibility and commitment, recognising that Schar’s role is vital to the team’s aspirations.
Newcastle’s triumph serves as a crucial moment, inviting fans and stakeholders to reflect on how sport intersects with larger socio-political realities. The club’s dedicated fanbase has a rich history of activism, empowering constructive conversations about sporting success that align with accountability for human rights abroad.
As supporters don their black and white jerseys this season, they must remember those directly affected by Saudi policies. Can celebrating this cup victory coexist with advocating for human rights? The narrative of Newcastle United must embrace a commitment to equity and justice both on and off the pitch.
Newcastle United celebrated a landmark win at the Carabao Cup Final, but the achievement raises moral questions regarding the club’s Saudi ownership amidst human rights violations. The case of Manahel al-Otaibi exemplifies the oppressive regime’s stance against dissenters, while migrant worker abuses and inadequate progress on women’s rights further highlight ongoing injustices. Fans are urged to reflect on these issues as part of the club’s narrative moving forward.
Newcastle United’s Carabao Cup victory, while historic, invites a deeper conversation about the ethical implications of the club’s Saudi ownership. The ongoing human rights abuses connected to this regime present a juxtaposition to the joy of winning; thus, fans are called to acknowledge these realities. By fostering conversations that uphold principles of equity and justice, the club can embrace a legacy that truly reflects its commitment to social justice, both in sports and beyond.
Original Source: evrimagaci.org
